I Maccheroni, Italian Osteria, Paddington

• ★★★★☆

  I might have set my hopes too high. I would’ve given it a 3 star but they deserve some encouragement. It’s a bit underwhelming, and the saltiness overpowers the flavors at least for the pasta. On a good note, the texture of the pasta is amazing and cooked perfectly al dente which surprisingly a lot of restaurants get wrong. The bread gave me such mixed feelings, the olive oil with balsamic is amazing, you can really taste the flavors in their olive oil, but the bread taste slightly stale which might be because that I came on a Sunday haha It’s still nice Italian food but it didn’t really surpr

  Olivia Yuan · a month ago

• ★★★★★

  This place is special to us. It’s not just a restaurant it’s an experience. The food is proper traditional Italian, full of flavour and always consistent. That’s rare. Every time we walk in it feels like stepping into Little Italy. Warm, welcoming, and the kind of place you choose for birthdays and celebrations because you know it won’t disappoint. What really stands out is the consistency. Whether it’s a busy Saturday night or a quiet weekday dinner, the quality never drops. The pasta is always perfectly cooked, the sauces taste homemade and authentic, and the portions are generous without co

  Victor Tringas · 8 months ago

• ★★★★★

  ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ My partner and I stumbled across I Maccheroni almost by accident. We picked it on a whim, walked about 20 minutes to get there, and it ended up being one of the best dining experiences we’ve ever had. Tucked away down a quiet street, the restaurant is a beautiful little gem. The intimate setting, with just a couple of tables outside, immediately caught our attention. We were seated at a lovely window table for two with beautiful lighting, elegant table settings, soft music, and the most wonderful aroma throughout the restaurant. Everything felt immaculate, welcoming and thoughtfully put

  Tannath Johnston · 4 months ago

• ★★★★★

  We have been to this restaurant many times and we always enjoy the food. Today we tried the $59 3 course meal. It was really enjoyable. Best for me was the zuccini flowers, pork ribs, beef cheek pasta and cannelloni for desert.

  Gary Bailey · a month ago

• ★★★★★

  $520 for 3 with cocktails, non-alcoholic wine and wine. Fabulous delicious lunch. Guaranteed food coma afterwards. Must experience. Must book ahead. Must go!

  F Liu · 3 months ago

Reviews are written by Google Maps users. Read all 1,173 reviews on Google